Skip to content

Violence Against Coptic Protesters is Evidence of Government Failure

October 10, 2011

Egypt's interim government needs to look for alternatives to violence when dealing with Coptic protests.

Violence, wrote Isaac Asimov, is the last refuge of the incompetent. In ambiguous situations–like the political uncertainties of a country trying to make a transition to civilian rule with an interim military government all apointed by the ousted regime–the quicker the move to violence as a solution to a problem, the more incompetent an actor is revealed to be.

What yesterday’s violence in Cairo shows, more than anything else, is how little creativity the military council and its appointed government show in the face of crisis and change, in the face of creative social change. 25 dead, almost 300 injured, and dozens detained and bound for secret military trials attest to the damage resulting from an inability to think outside the schemas and frameworks of the old regime

The demolition (or partial demolition; news reports are unclear) of a Christian church in a southern governorate (Aswan, in this case) is nothing new. What is new in post-Mubarak Egypt is that the Copts, and their secularist and Muslim friends, didn’t let it lie. They got out there in the street and protested.

The government reacted in the way the Mubarak regime did, under cover of the hated Emergency Law, by sending in armed police with armored police vehicles, arresting protesters and holding them “for investigation.” Police defended their actions by claiming that the protesters started the violence. All according to the script.

Prime Minister Essam Sheraf’s call for an “investigation” will be seen by most Egyptians as laughable. This call, too, is strictly according to the old regime playbook; everyone knows how effective such investigations are.

Imagine if, instead of trying to solve the problem of Copts and their fellow travelers protesting against sectarian violence by suppressing the protesters, they had tried something else? For example (off the top of my head):

  • Announce immediate passage of  the law, already recommended, equalizing rules for building mosques and churches
  • Create a national council for sectarian dialogue including an member of the Maspero Youth organization, an appointee of Pope Shenouda, a Muslim Brotherhood official, an appointee of the military, and a respected Salafi leader (one who has officially renounced violence, like Al-Gama’a al-Islamiyya leader Najeh Ibrahim), give them the authority to call witnesses, and a timetable to make recommendations on dealing with sectarian violence.
  • Announce a national fund to rebuild all demolished places of worship (including Sufi and Shi’ite shrines). Raise taxes in the communities where the damage occurred to help pay for it–but not on members of the offended sect. Since taxes in Egypt fall more heavily on the affluent than the poor, maybe local leaders will start policing the radicals in their midst.
  • Announce the immediate creation of a special national police task force charged exclusively with investigating attacks on religious sites; tie pay raises and promotions directly to successful prosecutions.

I’m sure with a class of bright grad students at AUC or Cairo University we could generate a dozen better ones.

None of these would be a complete solution to the problem of sectarianism in Egypt. To some extent such acts would be mere political theater.

But political theater is a necessary part of government; it is one of the ways the state speaks to the people. And what a different message actions like these would have sent to the people of Egypt, as they prepare for November elections, than the sight of armored police vehicles crushing the bodies of protesters.

One Comment leave one →
  1. Margaret Dalen permalink
    October 11, 2011 5:06 pm

    Mark, I really enjoy receiving your blogs and comments on the continuing situation in Egypt. As a tourist last January, I didn’t really see (or get) all of the ramifications of life in Egypt – just realized that something would need to change, but never thought that it would be the day after I left. Thanks for making me a more informed citizen of this world of ours. Marge

    Mark, I’m changing my email address, but will still receive at for a while. I’ll send another notice when I’m not at Mayo.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: